Monday, July 16, 2012

Example 9.38: dynamite plots, revisited

Dynamite plots are a somewhat pejorative term for a graphical display where the height of a bar indicates the mean, and the vertical line on top of it represents the standard deviation (or standard error). These displays are commonly found in many scientific disciplines, as a way of communicating group differences in means.

Many find these displays troubling. One post entitled them unmitigated evil.
The Vanderbilt University Department of Biostatistics has a formal policy discouraing use of these plots, stating that:

Dynamite plots often hide important information. This is particularly true of small or skewed data sets. Researchers are highly discouraged from using them, and department members have the option to decline participation in papers in which the lead author requires the use of these plots.

Despite the limitations of the display, we believe that there may be times when the display is helpful as a way to compare groups, assuming distributions that are approximately normal. Samuel Brown also described creation of these figures, as a way to encourage computing in R. We previously demonstrated how to create them in SAS and R, and today discuss code created by Randall Pruim to demonstrate how such graphics can be created using lattice graphics within the mosaic package.


dynamitePlot <- function(height, error, names = as.character(1:length(height)),
significance = NA, ylim = c(0, maxLim), ...) {
if (missing(error)) { error = 0 }
maxLim <- 1.2* max(mapply(sum, height, error))
mError <- min(c(error, na.rm=TRUE))
barchart(height ~ names, ylim=ylim, panel=function(x,y,...) {
grid.polyline(c(x,x), c(y, y+error), id=rep(x,2), default.units='native',
arrow=arrow(angle=45, length=unit(mError, 'native')))
grid.polyline(c(x,x), c(y, y-error), id=rep(x,2), default.units='native',
arrow=arrow(angle=45, length=unit(mError, 'native')))
grid.text(x=x, y=y + error + .05*maxLim, label=significance,
}, ...)

Much of the code involves setting up the appropriate axis limits, then drawing the lines and adding the text. We can call this new function with an artificial example with 4 groups:

Values <- c(1,2,5,4)
Errors <- c(0.25, 0.5, 0.33, 0.12)
Names <- paste("Trial", 1:4)
Sig <- c("a", "a", "b", "b")
dynamitePlot(Values, Errors, names=Names, significance=Sig)

We still don't recommend frequent use of these plots (as other displays may be better (e.g. dotplots for very small sample sizes or violin plots), but having the capability to generate dynamite plots within the lattice framework can be handy.

An unrelated note about aggregators:We love aggregators! Aggregators collect blogs that have similar coverage for the convenience of readers, and for blog authors they offer a way to reach new audiences. SAS and R is aggregated by R-bloggers, PROC-X, and statsblogs with our permission, and by at least 2 other aggregating services which have never contacted us. If you read this on an aggregator that does not credit the blogs it incorporates, please come visit us at SAS and R. We answer comments there and offer direct subscriptions if you like our content. In addition, no one is allowed to profit by this work under our license; if you see advertisements on this page, the aggregator is violating the terms by which we publish our work.


Chris Andrews said...

I think this code qualifies as "aiding and abetting" :-)

Nick Horton said...

I can't dispute your statement, and appreciate the smiley face.

Let me also state publicly that both Ken and Randy shared these sentiments, but I still thought it useful to share the details of how one might solve this problem using lattice.

I also want to make it clear that I've never generated or used one of these (though I have had biology collaborators who will use this type of graph, despite my best efforts).

I don't sound defensive, do I? :-)

Dominican Republic 2024 said...

Perhaps we should insert the following lines of code into the example above:

warning("You are using a dynamite plot. There is probably a better plot for your data.")
warning("The author of this code does not endorse or condone the use of dynamite plots.")
warning("Use at your own risk.")

As I recall, my involvement in this came from the angle of "how would you do something like this in lattice?". If this code encourages more people to use lattice (and move away from dynamite plots), then I'm happy I did it. If this code actually leads to more people making dynamite plots, I'm sorry.

Ken Kleinman said...

Maybe it should be

dynomiteplot = function(x,y) {
vioplot(x[y==0], x[y==1])